| Year | ACC# | Set Name | Card # | Price | Photo | Variation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1887 | N175 | Gypsy Queens | Bat at 45-Correct spell Buffinton | |||
| 1887 | N690 | Kalamazoo Bats | Correct spell Buffinton | |||
| 1887 | N690-1 | Kalamazoo Bats Cabinets | 7 | |||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 50-1a | Pitch-hands chest high-C.F., Phila. | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 50-1b | Pitch-hands chest high-Centre Field | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 50-1c | Pitch-hands chest high-Philadelphias | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 50-2a | Bat at ready-C.F., Phila. | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 50-2b | Bat at ready-P., Phila's | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 50-3a | Pitch-R/hand above head-C.F., Phila. | ||
| 1888 | E223 | G & B Chewing Gum | Photo portrait-Correct spell Buffinton | |||
| 1888 | N403 | Yum Yum Tobacco | Correct spell Buffinton | |||
| 1889 | E.R. Williams Card Game | 4 |
